Reviews: how they work and who responds

Reviews drive your search ranking and future bookings on Airbnb and Vrbo, and a thoughtful response to every review, good or bad, is part of managing them well.

After each stay, both the guest and the host can review the experience, and those reviews become part of your listing's public record. Future guests read them closely, and the platforms factor ratings into how prominently your home appears in search. A pattern of strong reviews compounds over time; a neglected one does quiet, lasting damage.

How the process works

On both Airbnb and Vrbo, reviews are typically double-blind for a window after checkout: neither side sees the other's review until both are submitted or the window closes. That design encourages honesty. Guests rate categories like cleanliness, accuracy, and communication alongside an overall score, and hosts review the guest as well, which feeds the screening system for future bookings.

Responding matters

  • Positive reviews deserve a brief, warm thank-you. It signals to future guests that a real, attentive host stands behind the listing.
  • Critical reviews deserve a calm, factual reply: acknowledge the issue, state what was fixed, and never argue. Other guests judge your professionalism by that response more than by the complaint itself.
  • Reviews that break platform policy, such as retaliatory or irrelevant content, can be reported for removal through the platform's process.

Behind the scenes, reviews are also an operations tool: repeated comments about the same detail, a confusing lock, a missing pan, point straight at fixes. With Buckeye managing your property, we respond to reviews, leave guest reviews on your behalf, and fold the feedback into cleaning and maintenance checklists.

More in Bookings & Guests

Article • Bookings & Guests Early check-in and late check-out requests Guests often ask to arrive early or leave late, and whether the answer is yes depends on the calendar around their stay and the time needed to turn your home over properly. Article • Bookings & Guests House rules and problem guests: how they're handled Clear house rules set expectations before guests arrive, and our team handles problems calmly and documents everything if a stay goes wrong. Article • Bookings & Guests How are guests screened? Guest screening combines platform verification tools, booking patterns, and clear communication before arrival to reduce the risk of problem stays at your home. Article • Bookings & Guests How do check-in and check-out work? Check-in and check-out run on clear instructions, reliable access, and a turnover window in between, so guests arrive to a ready home and leave it ready for the next stay. Article • Bookings & Guests How do my calendars stay in sync across Airbnb and Vrbo? How calendar sync keeps your Airbnb and Vrbo availability matched, prevents most double bookings, and what you should still check yourself. Article • Bookings & Guests How parties and unauthorized guests are prevented Preventing parties and unauthorized guests starts long before check-in, with the right listing settings, clear rules, and active attention during each stay. Article • Bookings & Guests Long stays and extending a booking Longer stays and mid-stay extensions can be some of the most valuable bookings your rental gets, as long as pricing, cleaning, and local rules are handled correctly. Article • Bookings & Guests What happens when a guest cancels? Cancellations are handled under the policy set on your listing, and our team works to reopen and rebook the dates whenever a guest cancels. Article • Bookings & Guests Who communicates with guests? With full-service management, the Buckeye ARM team handles guest messaging from the first inquiry through checkout, so you never have to be on call.

← Back to the Help Center

Want us to handle it?

Buckeye manages short-term rentals across Central Ohio — listings, pricing, guests, cleaning, and statements.