Should I make my rental pet-friendly?

Welcoming pets opens your home to a large group of travelers, but it changes cleaning, wear, and rules; here is the honest trade-off.

Many travelers will not book a home that refuses their dog, so allowing pets can meaningfully widen your audience. It is not the right call for every property, though, and the decision should be made with cleaning and wear in mind.

The upside

  • More demand: pet owners actively filter for pet-friendly homes and often book longer stays.
  • Loyal guests: travelers with pets return to homes that worked well for them.
  • Competitive edge: in neighborhoods where few listings allow pets, yours stands out immediately.

The costs to plan for

  • Deeper cleaning: turnovers need extra attention to hair, odors, and floors, which your cleaning coordination should account for.
  • Wear and tear: scratched doors and stained rugs happen occasionally; durable finishes help.
  • Association rules: some communities restrict animals, which settles the question before it starts.

If you say yes, set it up properly

State clear rules in the listing: number and size of pets, whether they may be left alone, and yard expectations. Provide food bowls, old towels, and a covered trash can so guests can be tidy easily.

Our team can walk through your specific home and help you decide. For many Central Ohio properties near trails and parks, pet-friendly ends up being a profitable yes.

One more consideration is your other guests. A deep, consistent cleaning standard between stays protects guests with allergies who book after a dog has visited, so the decision only works when turnover quality stays high every single time.

More in Your Listing

Article • Your Listing Amenities guests expect (and notice when they're missing) The everyday amenities short-term rental guests assume will be there, from fast Wi-Fi and coffee to enough towels โ€” and the small gaps that show up in reviews. Article • Your Listing How should I set minimum stays? Minimum stay settings balance revenue against turnover costs; the right pattern usually changes between weekends, weekdays, and big events. Article • Your Listing How to make your listing stand out Practical ways to help your short-term rental listing earn clicks, bookings, and good reviews: honest photos, clear writing, and details guests actually scan for. Article • Your Listing Setting up a family-friendly rental Families book longer stays and treat homes gently; a few thoughtful touches make your rental the obvious choice for them. Article • Your Listing Setting up for remote-work guests Remote workers book longer, quieter stays; a real workspace, strong Wi-Fi, and a few thoughtful extras win their business. Article • Your Listing Should I turn on Instant Book? Instant Book removes friction for guests and can lift bookings, but it trades away some screening control; here is how to weigh it. Article • Your Listing Updating your listing with the seasons A listing written once slowly drifts out of date; seasonal refreshes keep photos, amenities, and pricing aligned with what guests want now. Article • Your Listing What makes listing photos book nights? Why some listing photos turn browsers into bookings: light, order, honest framing, and showing the experience guests are actually shopping for. Article • Your Listing Writing a title and description that get bookings Your title earns the click and your description earns the booking; both should be specific, honest, and focused on the guest's stay.

← Back to the Help Center

Want us to handle it?

Buckeye manages short-term rentals across Central Ohio โ€” listings, pricing, guests, cleaning, and statements.